5.26.2015
CALL Literary Reaction Journal 2
Reaction to How Do I Love Thee? written by Elizabeth Barret Browning.
1. Summary
'I' have a problem how do he/she love 'thee', and enumerate the way. 'I' answer his/her own question in the poem. At the end, 'I' tell he/she will love 'thee' more after death than lifetime.
2.Reaction
~Simile~
The part:
I love thee freely, as men strive for Right;
I love thee purely, as they turn from Praise.
has simile. I agree with the latter simile since praise is expression of respect to God, and God is innocent. But I cannot accept the former. I think striving is not freely because they want to make something change so they are restricted by the opposite.
~Hyperbole~
The expression:
I love thee with the breath, smiles, tears, of all my life!
is hyperbole. It exaggrates love more than such words 'I love thee all time/everyday.' So it would tell me 'I' love 'thee' so much beyond description.
~Theme~
As you know, the theme of this poem is love and it is lyric poetry. Love exist everywhere; among friends, families, lovers, etc. However I think 'I' and 'thee' are lovers.
3.General Opinion
I cannnot understand the last of the poem. I supoose 'if God choose' means if someone die, but in this case who is chosen 'I' or 'thee'? Please tell me your opinion.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hello Tsugumi,
ReplyDeleteMay I say that I very much enjoyed reading your analysis. I thought your comments on each of the reaction points were very perceptive. You very correctly identify examples of simile and then make very sharp, incisive comments about each. Additionally, your discussion of both Hyperbole and Theme are spot-on!
Great post!
Hello Tsugumi.
ReplyDeleteI read this poetry this time, too.
I cannnot understand the last of the poem too. So I want to share an opinion.
Thank you, Rina. How do you think about it?
DeleteHello Tsugumi! I enjoyed reading your opinion. In my opinion about the last line of this poem, "if God choose" means "if God choose I", because "if God choose, I shall" seems that "I" will follow God. Sorry for my poor English. Thank you for sharing your opinion :)
ReplyDeleteThank you, Chisato. Your opinion is interesting and convincing!
ReplyDeleteHi,Tsugumi
ReplyDeleteIt is the poetry that very passionate, is beautiful.
I feel sacredness.
Thank you, Minami. I feel this poetry is passionate, too.
DeleteHello,Tsugumi.
ReplyDeleteI read your blog, I thought 'love' is difficult thema.
Hello, Tsugumi.I was able to deepen the understanding of the poetry by reading your blog. But I cannot understand the last of poem.
ReplyDeleteHello Tsugumi. I read your Literary Journal Reaction. I think your opinion is very good! I would like to read this story.
ReplyDeleteHello Tsugumi. I read your Literary Journal Reaction. I think your opinion is very good! I would like to read this story.
ReplyDelete